Historic Homes for Sale in The Hamptons: Exploring Architectural Heritage

The Hamptons, known for its sandy beaches, prestigious summer retreats, and A-list residents, also hold a wealth of historic treasures. From saltbox homes dating back to the 1600s to grand mansions from the 1800s, the region offers a unique blend of heritage and history.

Buyers seeking homes with character both inside and out a deep-rooted historical lineage will find a wealth of options throughout the East End. From the hamlets and villages of Southampton to the easternmost stretch of East Hampton, wherever you buy, rest assured many of the properties reflect centuries of craftsmanship. It's not uncommon to encounter homes that have survived multiple eras and witnessed the evolution of the region's distinct culture.

Of course, the allure of owning a historic home in the Hamptons is undeniable, offering a piece of architectural history and a chance to live in residences that embody the timeless charm and elegance of bygone eras. Let's explore some of the most notable historic homes currently listed for sale in the Hamptons.

"Aunt Phoebe's Saltbox," located at 21 Hither Lane, is one of East Hampton's most treasured historic homes. Originally built in the 19th century, this traditional saltbox was relocated to Hither Lane in 1926 under the direction of architect Joseph Greenleaf Thorp, who ensured the home's architectural integrity remained intact. Today, the house stands on a sprawling 1.8-acre lot and has been expanded to approximately 4,000 square feet, preserving its historical charm through matched and sourced materials. The timber frame structure is a rare and protected example of early Long Island architecture, and the property's designation ensures it maintains its historical authenticity while offering the opportunity to expand further with additional structures.

The first of two Sag Harbor homes on our list, the Nathan P. Howell House is a stunning example of Greek Revival and Italianate architecture. Constructed in 1833, this Sag Harbor gem exudes grandeur with its meticulously restored facade, intricate millwork, and soaring 11-foot ceilings. The craftsmanship that defines this 10,000-square-foot home speaks to a bygone era, while thoughtful updates ensure it remains a luxurious residence that lives up to modern standards. The home's multiple fireplaces, wide-plank hardwood floors, and original hardware reflect its historical significance, while modern amenities like a well-appointed, state-of-the-art kitchen and a climate-controlled artist studio ensure comfort and convenience. The property's proximity to Sag Harbor Village and its large, beautifully landscaped lot make it an exceptional offering for those seeking both history and luxury.

A block away from the Howell House, just beyond the Sag Harbor Whaling Museum, is the Hannibal French House. An architectural masterpiece on Sag Harbor's historic Captain's Row, the 1834-built home was expanded in 1860, with several restorations since, including one by acclaimed interior designer Veere Grenney. This careful curation of the property's lineage is apparent upon an initial tour. The grand ballroom, formal dining room, and ten fireplaces speak to the opulence of the period, while the gourmet kitchen and updated amenities make it ideal for modern lifestyles. The property's manicured gardens, covered deck, and heated pool provide a serene outdoor escape, perfectly complementing the home's architectural grandeur.

An absolutely stunning property set along East Hampton Village's exclusive Egypt Lane, this one-acre, 1920s French Provincial-style estate seamlessly blends old-world elegance with contemporary updates. It offers a rare glimpse into the Hamptons' architectural evolution. While boasting all the modern comforts expected in a luxury home, the residence typifies Hamptons' grace and sophistication. The home's observation deck offers views of the nearby Maidstone Club, Hook Pond, and the Atlantic, making it a truly unique retreat. Original aesthetic details from the 1920s remain, ensuring the home maintains its historical bonafides, while modern renovations, such as a heated pool and pool house, add to its contemporary appeal.

One of East Hampton's most iconic residences, the Frederick G. Potter House, is a grand shingle-style cottage designed by architect Joseph Greenleaf Thorp in 1905. Situated at the entrance of Lily Pond Lane, this estate offers commanding views from Hook Pond to the Atlantic Ocean. The home's spacious rooms, charming details, and expansive porches exude a classy, timeless aura, while the meticulously landscaped grounds, including a pool and pool house, offer ample space for relaxation. With 14 bedrooms and nine bathrooms across its three stories, this home is a testament to the grandeur of early 20th-century Hamptons architecture. Its proximity to Main Beach and Hook Pond ensures that it remains one of the most sought-after properties in the area.

The Hamptons offer plenty of opportunities for those interested in restoration, including this charming 1880s cedar-shingled home on North Main Street in Southampton. It posits an incredible chance for historic home enthusiasts; with approved Architectural Review plans, this residence is ready for a transformation, allowing a discerning owner with an eye for design and preservation to create a truly unique space. The house retains its historic character, with original fireplaces, a slate terrace, and an artist's studio once used by American artist Henry Koehler. The lot, which includes plans for a gunite pool and pool house, offers the perfect canvas for a modern luxury estate steeped in history. Less than a third of a mile from Southampton's vibrant village center, this home represents the ideal blend of historic charm and contemporary convenience.

Known as "Nunnakoma," which means "on the shore," this beautiful shingle-style waterfront home in the Village of Quogue lives up to the moniker while showcasing the endearing historical aesthetic of Hamptons' turn-of-the-20th-century architecture. Built with the finest materials and boasting impeccable craftsmanship, this home offers sweeping water views and luxurious living spaces. With eight bedrooms, seven bathrooms, and a variety of porches that invite you to soak in the bay vistas, Nunnakoma is the epitome of waterfront living. Every detail of the home thoughtfully reflects the region's charm. An extensive update at the turn of the 21st century ensured the property would play host to future generations of East Enders.

Finally, we take a jaunt up to the serenity of Shelter Island and a 1901-built, Tudor-style residence. Offering a glimpse into the early 20th-century craftsmanship, a recent and thoughtfully executed renovation restored this highly distinctive residence to its original glory while ensuring modern buyers a comfortable place to call home. The house retains its original six fireplaces, each upgraded for current-day efficiency. The updates also found space for a butler's pantry and new HVAC systems while maintaining the quirks and accouterments that make Tudor homes such distinguished architectural showcases. The property also features a heated 20 x 50 Gunite pool and a deep water dock with space for multiple watercraft, perfect for boating enthusiasts.

The Hamptons offer a rare opportunity to own homes that are not only luxurious but also steeped in history. These properties, each with their own unique architectural heritage, represent the enduring charm and character that maintains the Hamptons real estate market as one of the world's most desirable.

If you're in the market for a historic, high-end property or planning to sell one, contact Andrea Ackerman today to start your Hamptons real estate journey. Allow Andrea's experience and expertise to help you navigate this sought-after region and ensure a successful and lucrative transaction.